ML
    • Recent
    • Categories
    • Tags
    • Popular
    • Users
    • Groups
    • Register
    • Login

    Struggling to Understand Kernel and OS Separation

    IT Discussion
    linux kernel curtis operating system unix computer basics
    18
    129
    17.5k
    Loading More Posts
    • Oldest to Newest
    • Newest to Oldest
    • Most Votes
    Reply
    • Reply as topic
    Log in to reply
    This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
    • C
      cnewman @scottalanmiller
      last edited by gjacobse

      @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

      @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

      Please show me my response to that and let's get back to the REAL subject you;re avoiding the Linux Kernel

      That's been covered thoroughly. We are waiting for you to figure out what you got wrong, contact the sources you have (that don't exist) and send us their responses. The ball is in your court. As I said, asking us to do anything further to contact your sources and correct them (or to show that they agreed) is the same as admitting you made it up.

      Awesome you have no balls, sorry about that, THE LINUX KERNEL MY MAN WHAT ABOUT THAT DUDE?

      He already asked you how you use the Kernel. But you never answered.

      Ignorant question, I said to tell at LEAST Linux.com they are stupid for saying it's an OS BUT YOU FAILED TO DO SO = NO BALLS

      This is the standard pattern. A simple question, you say you'll prove something, we say "okay, prove it", then... gibberish answer as to why you suddenly don't know what a kernel is. As expected.
      Your quote not mine

      0_1473470427250_kernel.jpg

      So you screenshotted something that I said, that you said was wrong, to show that YOU know the answer? I know what a kernel is. You said that Linux is an OS, not the kernel. So since Linux is not the kernel, what kernel are YOU talking about? I know which one I am talking about.

      I'm not talking about a Kernel Both Windows and Linux are written Kernels, but IS NOT A KERNEL it is and OS Unix is a Kernel with NO UI or GUI you ignorant f[moderated]

      S S 3 Replies Last reply Reply Quote -5
      • S
        stacksofplates @cnewman
        last edited by gjacobse

        @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

        @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

        Please show me my response to that and let's get back to the REAL subject you;re avoiding the Linux Kernel

        That's been covered thoroughly. We are waiting for you to figure out what you got wrong, contact the sources you have (that don't exist) and send us their responses. The ball is in your court. As I said, asking us to do anything further to contact your sources and correct them (or to show that they agreed) is the same as admitting you made it up.

        Awesome you have no balls, sorry about that, THE LINUX KERNEL MY MAN WHAT ABOUT THAT DUDE?

        He already asked you how you use the Kernel. But you never answered.

        Ignorant question, I said to tell at LEAST Linux.com they are stupid for saying it's an OS BUT YOU FAILED TO DO SO = NO BALLS

        This is the standard pattern. A simple question, you say you'll prove something, we say "okay, prove it", then... gibberish answer as to why you suddenly don't know what a kernel is. As expected.
        Your quote not mine

        0_1473470427250_kernel.jpg

        So you screenshotted something that I said, that you said was wrong, to show that YOU know the answer? I know what a kernel is. You said that Linux is an OS, not the kernel. So since Linux is not the kernel, what kernel are YOU talking about? I know which one I am talking about.

        I'm not talking about a Kernel Both Windows and Linux are written Kernels, but IS NOT A KERNEL it is and OS Unix is a Kernel with NO UI or GUI you ignorant f[moderated]

        A. This sentence does not make sense.
        B. Stop being rude.
        C. Please learn how stuff works.

        C 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
        • C
          cnewman @stacksofplates
          last edited by gjacobse

          @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

          @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

          Please show me my response to that and let's get back to the REAL subject you;re avoiding the Linux Kernel

          That's been covered thoroughly. We are waiting for you to figure out what you got wrong, contact the sources you have (that don't exist) and send us their responses. The ball is in your court. As I said, asking us to do anything further to contact your sources and correct them (or to show that they agreed) is the same as admitting you made it up.

          Awesome you have no balls, sorry about that, THE LINUX KERNEL MY MAN WHAT ABOUT THAT DUDE?

          He already asked you how you use the Kernel. But you never answered.

          Ignorant question, I said to tell at LEAST Linux.com they are stupid for saying it's an OS BUT YOU FAILED TO DO SO = NO BALLS

          This is the standard pattern. A simple question, you say you'll prove something, we say "okay, prove it", then... gibberish answer as to why you suddenly don't know what a kernel is. As expected.
          Your quote not mine

          0_1473470427250_kernel.jpg

          So you screenshotted something that I said, that you said was wrong, to show that YOU know the answer? I know what a kernel is. You said that Linux is an OS, not the kernel. So since Linux is not the kernel, what kernel are YOU talking about? I know which one I am talking about.

          I'm not talking about a Kernel Both Windows and Linux are written Kernels, but IS NOT A KERNEL it is and OS Unix is a Kernel with NO UI or GUI you ignorant f[moderated]

          A. This sentence does not make sense.
          B. Stop being rude.
          C. Please learn how stuff works.

          Does Unix automatically expand disc space like Windows?

          S S 2 Replies Last reply Reply Quote -3
          • S
            stacksofplates @cnewman
            last edited by gjacobse

            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

            Please show me my response to that and let's get back to the REAL subject you;re avoiding the Linux Kernel

            That's been covered thoroughly. We are waiting for you to figure out what you got wrong, contact the sources you have (that don't exist) and send us their responses. The ball is in your court. As I said, asking us to do anything further to contact your sources and correct them (or to show that they agreed) is the same as admitting you made it up.

            Awesome you have no balls, sorry about that, THE LINUX KERNEL MY MAN WHAT ABOUT THAT DUDE?

            He already asked you how you use the Kernel. But you never answered.

            Ignorant question, I said to tell at LEAST Linux.com they are stupid for saying it's an OS BUT YOU FAILED TO DO SO = NO BALLS

            This is the standard pattern. A simple question, you say you'll prove something, we say "okay, prove it", then... gibberish answer as to why you suddenly don't know what a kernel is. As expected.
            Your quote not mine

            0_1473470427250_kernel.jpg

            So you screenshotted something that I said, that you said was wrong, to show that YOU know the answer? I know what a kernel is. You said that Linux is an OS, not the kernel. So since Linux is not the kernel, what kernel are YOU talking about? I know which one I am talking about.

            I'm not talking about a Kernel Both Windows and Linux are written Kernels, but IS NOT A KERNEL it is and OS Unix is a Kernel with NO UI or GUI you ignorant f[moderated]

            A. This sentence does not make sense.
            B. Stop being rude.
            C. Please learn how stuff works.

            Does Unix automatically expand disc space like Windows?

            I'm going to assume you're talking about thin provisioning. Yes, you can thin provision logical volumes.

            C 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
            • S
              scottalanmiller @cnewman
              last edited by

              @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

              I'm not talking about a Kernel Both Windows and Linux are written Kernels,

              You said a kernel. And what is a "written kernel." So if you didn't mean a kernel, what did you mean when you said you would show me up on using the kernel?

              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
              • S
                scottalanmiller @cnewman
                last edited by gjacobse

                @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                but IS NOT A KERNEL it is and OS Unix is a Kernel with NO UI or GUI you ignorant f[moderated]

                Now now, you seem a little upset. I'm just repeating what you said.

                I'm writing this to you from a Linux system with a GUI. Which part is wrong. Is it not Linux? Is it not a GUI? Do you need a screenshot? The community is full of Linux GUI screenshots. UI, GUI... all write here that I am typing on.

                AGAIN..... totally non-plausible lies.

                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                • C
                  cnewman @stacksofplates
                  last edited by

                  @stacksofplates
                  @scottalanmiller
                  It seems I'll have to email these sites to confirm Linux is NOT an Operating and is ONLY a Kernel as a system as Scott Stated, I'll do so on Monday.

                  End of discussion.

                  S S RojoLocoR 4 Replies Last reply Reply Quote -3
                  • S
                    stacksofplates @cnewman
                    last edited by

                    @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                    @stacksofplates
                    @scottalanmiller
                    It seems I'll have to email these sites to confirm Linux is NOT an Operating and is ONLY a Kernel as a system as Scott Stated, I'll do so on Monday.

                    End of discussion.

                    Please make sure they CC us on the response. I'm waiting with bated breath.

                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                    • S
                      stacksofplates @cnewman
                      last edited by

                      @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                      @stacksofplates
                      @scottalanmiller
                      It seems I'll have to email these sites to confirm Linux is NOT an Operating and is ONLY a Kernel as a system as Scott Stated, I'll do so on Monday.

                      End of discussion.

                      You could always do it now, just program the email. Then use the GUI on the Kernel to hit the send button.

                      S 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                      • S
                        scottalanmiller @cnewman
                        last edited by

                        @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                        @stacksofplates
                        @scottalanmiller
                        It seems I'll have to email these sites to confirm Linux is NOT an Operating and is ONLY a Kernel as a system as Scott Stated, I'll do so on Monday.

                        End of discussion.

                        It seems? That seems odd. How was it not totally clear. You go do that. Send them the link to this thread, we want them to participate. It would be best if the discussion was totally in public. If they feel that Linux is the OS, rather than the kernel, they should be happy to post here and explain why.

                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                        • S
                          scottalanmiller @stacksofplates
                          last edited by

                          @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

                          @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                          @stacksofplates
                          @scottalanmiller
                          It seems I'll have to email these sites to confirm Linux is NOT an Operating and is ONLY a Kernel as a system as Scott Stated, I'll do so on Monday.

                          End of discussion.

                          You could always do it now, just program the email. Then use the GUI on the Kernel to hit the send button.

                          Yeah, email works around the clock... unless you were planning on sending this from your BBS system and your time slot hasn't come up yet.

                          I'm waiting on the email address for Offix right now, I'll email them right this second if you provide it. You asked me to reach out to them, but I dont want to call them now and just leave a message. But I'll email straight away,

                          S 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                          • S
                            stacksofplates @scottalanmiller
                            last edited by

                            @scottalanmiller said in What is a Linux Distro:

                            @stacksofplates said in What is a Linux Distro:

                            @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                            @stacksofplates
                            @scottalanmiller
                            It seems I'll have to email these sites to confirm Linux is NOT an Operating and is ONLY a Kernel as a system as Scott Stated, I'll do so on Monday.

                            End of discussion.

                            You could always do it now, just program the email. Then use the GUI on the Kernel to hit the send button.

                            Yeah, email works around the clock... unless you were planning on sending this from your BBS system and your time slot hasn't come up yet.

                            I'm waiting on the email address for Offix right now, I'll email them right this second if you provide it. You asked me to reach out to them, but I dont want to call them now and just leave a message. But I'll email straight away,

                            svalenta@offix.com

                            S 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                            • S
                              scottalanmiller @stacksofplates
                              last edited by

                              @stacksofplates thanks! I'm on it. Want to email him too? 😉

                              1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                              • thwrT
                                thwr @cnewman
                                last edited by thwr

                                @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                                Now email them and ell them that Linux is a Kernel, if not I'll bring this thread to their attention to correct you. I mean windows has a Kernel too right?
                                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_kernel

                                Linux is a Kernel like Windows with a UI or GUI

                                Unix is much different except Apple OSX is written over top of a Unix Kernel. C'mon man WTF is wrong with you

                                OS X is based on NextStep, which is based on BSD which is based on UNIX. Similar to Linux, there are different flavors like FreeBSD, OpenBSD and NetBSD.

                                Here's some simplified chart to show you the relations between and origins of Linux, BSD and OS X:
                                 A picture showing the relations between several Unix systems.
                                (Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Unix_timeline.en.svg)

                                1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                • thwrT
                                  thwr @cnewman
                                  last edited by thwr

                                  @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                                  Yes Printers are Programmable, I mean how do you think they do what the y do now, F)(&*ing Magic

                                  Don't want to divert the thread, but I'm curious: What exactly are you developing? New PCL interpreters? Embedded networking stacks? Printer management software, e.g. job scheduling, accounting and similar things? Form management?

                                  I'm just asking because I am myself a developer with a little embedded background here and there.

                                  thwrT 1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                  • thwrT
                                    thwr @thwr
                                    last edited by

                                    @thwr said in What is a Linux Distro:

                                    @cnewman said in What is a Linux Distro:

                                    Yes Printers are Programmable, I mean how do you think they do what the y do now, F)(&*ing Magic

                                    Don't want to divert the thread, but I'm curious: What exactly are you developing? New PCL interpreters? Embedded networking stacks? Printer management software, e.g. job scheduling, accounting and similar things? Form management?

                                    I'm just asking because I am myself a developer with a little embedded background here and there.

                                    Nevermind, there is a dedicated thread for this: https://mangolassi.it/topic/10680/programming-printers

                                    1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                    • S
                                      scottalanmiller
                                      last edited by

                                      @cnewman we reached out to your reference but, unfortunately, he was unable to speak for you as you had hoped and only wanted to clarify that you were his customer, not someone who worked for him.

                                      0_1473517411152_Screenshot from 2016-09-10 10-23-11.png

                                      But you can see that now that we are not BBS dependent, email works around the clock. We no longer have to wait until Monday to send a message and often times people will even respond before working hours. Given the modern, multicultural world, what is the weekend to some is working days to others. So waiting for your own working hours to attempt messaging really is not as sensible as would have been in the phone-only or intra-office mail days of the 1960s. And email is now essentially always instant as email systems as "always on" today, rather than connecting only from time to time like with your telnet-connection BBS examples that you show.

                                      1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 1
                                      • S
                                        scottalanmiller
                                        last edited by

                                        Maybe @cnewman you meant to give us the email address of your actual employer but got confused as to which was which? If you'd like to try again, we'll contact another company for you and see if they are willing to vouch for you? What's reference number two going to be?

                                        1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 2
                                        • S
                                          scottalanmiller @cnewman
                                          last edited by

                                          @cnewman said in Struggling to Understand Kernel and OS Separation:

                                          Does Unix automatically expand disc space like Windows?

                                          Unix is not an OS. So blue run as fast as Usain Bolt? See, it's nonsensical. That's why we have these explanations about kernel vs. OS, API vs. kernel, etc. And this is why semantics and accuracy always matter in IT.

                                          If you just use words that you have heard and don't know what they are or what they represent, you end up asking questions that have no meaning.

                                          1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 0
                                          • JaredBuschJ
                                            JaredBusch
                                            last edited by

                                            Do not forget that the linux.com link he provided actually says exactly what we have been saying. I quoted it earlier.

                                            1 Reply Last reply Reply Quote 5
                                            • 1
                                            • 2
                                            • 3
                                            • 4
                                            • 5
                                            • 6
                                            • 7
                                            • 5 / 7
                                            • First post
                                              Last post