Healthcare Sharing Networks - Have You Used One?
-
-
@MattSpeller said:
This whole thread top to bottom blows my mind
There is a reason that Americans travel all over the world for "healthcare tourism."
-
@coliver amongst other things! Trusting a closed system supposedly built on faith that does not publish it's financials, excluding anyone not of faith (or the wrong faith), paying extortionate amounts of money to get health care....
Edit: our system isn't awesome, no doubt. Here's an eye opener though - go punch in your salary here.
http://www.ees-financial.com/calculators/TakeHomePayCalculator.htm
-
It is true that it's cheaper to travel for healthcare. I have to have some VERY major surgery in the next couple years. I will be going to Spain most likely. The cost of travel a 3 week stay at a health care resort and the surgery etc. is only about $10k. That is a in room nurse private room for me an husband and all travel costs food etc.
-
-
@NetworkNerdWifey said:
Also I think someone asked about the tax thing - yes, we are covered as far as not having to pay the penalty tax. HCSN are allowed under ACA. We have a tax form that we will submit at tax time.
Not worried about the penalty tax... Concerned about the you getting money and not paying taxes on it. Here in Nebraska (and maybe this is federal) you have to report all sources of income. Technically this would be a source of income I would think - but perhaps it's not -it's just so darned weird...
-
@MattSpeller said:
http://www.ees-financial.com/calculators/TakeHomePayCalculator.htm
I love how this has a starting salary of $200K. Is that a normal pay in Canada?
-
Can an American just fly to these other countries and get healthcare and pay cash? How does that effect those who are waiting for those same surgeries in the country?
-
Yes....
-
@Minion-Queen said:
Yes....
and the second part of my question? I don't know about Spain, but I have heard that in Germany if you only get the government provided healthcare, and don't care additional coverage, there are long waits for surgical procedures.
-
@MattSpeller said:
http://www.ees-financial.com/calculators/TakeHomePayCalculator.htm
Those tax rates (not counting deductions) seem very similar to US tax rates.
Here is the Federal only tax portion. At $100K = 28% At $200K = 33%
For Nebraska it's an additional 6.84% over $27K (individual)
For New York it's an additional 8+% depending on countySo someone in Nebraska pays roughly 34.84%
and in NY pays roughly 36.84%These numbers seem pretty darned close to Canada's numbers.
-
@Dashrender said:
@Minion-Queen said:
Yes....
and the second part of my question? I don't know about Spain, but I have heard that in Germany if you only get the government provided healthcare, and don't care additional coverage, there are long waits for surgical procedures.
If you set these things up ahead of time. Also Germany wouldn't be a place you would go either for a health care destination.
-
@Dashrender said:
and the second part of my question? I don't know about Spain, but I have heard that in Germany if you only get the government provided healthcare, and don't care additional coverage, there are long waits for surgical procedures.
That's total BS. That's what Americans repeat. Germany do NOT wait for healthcare services. Anyone telling you about waits anywhere outside of the US is flat out lying. It's because just one of those things that they've repeated enough that they think that they can get away with claiming it. It's utterly ridiculous. It's totally unfounded.
Every time someone says that, it's always based on the hope that no one will know how to talk to someone in those countries to confirm it. They say it about Canada and the UK, places known for poor healthcase, and they certainly don't have those problems. Places like central Europe (Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Switzerland) that lead the world in healthcare do NOT have those kinds of problems. Their healthcare is cheap and fantastic.
-
@Minion-Queen said:
If you set these things up ahead of time. Also Germany wouldn't be a place you would go either for a health care destination.
Not if you can get to France, Italy or Spain. But if you are an American, Germany is so much better that it looks like Spain by comparison to what you are used to.
-
@Dashrender said:
@NetworkNerdWifey said:
Also I think someone asked about the tax thing - yes, we are covered as far as not having to pay the penalty tax. HCSN are allowed under ACA. We have a tax form that we will submit at tax time.
Not worried about the penalty tax... Concerned about the you getting money and not paying taxes on it. Here in Nebraska (and maybe this is federal) you have to report all sources of income. Technically this would be a source of income I would think - but perhaps it's not -it's just so darned weird...
You don't consider NORMAL insurance to be a form of income, right?
-
@Dashrender said:
@MattSpeller said:
http://www.ees-financial.com/calculators/TakeHomePayCalculator.htm
I love how this has a starting salary of $200K. Is that a normal pay in Canada?
Sure, that's like minimum wage in the US
-
@Dashrender said:
@MattSpeller said:
http://www.ees-financial.com/calculators/TakeHomePayCalculator.htm
Those tax rates (not counting deductions) seem very similar to US tax rates.
Most countries that give free healthcare have taxes relatively similar to the US (if you don't count healthcare cost as a tax, which it is.) If you include mandatory taxes like your health insurance, the US has some of the highest taxes in the world. They keep calling healthcare "insurance" rather than a "tax" to hide how high the taxes are.
-
@scottalanmiller said:
@Dashrender said:
and the second part of my question? I don't know about Spain, but I have heard that in Germany if you only get the government provided healthcare, and don't care additional coverage, there are long waits for surgical procedures.
That's total BS. That's what Americans repeat. Germany do NOT wait for healthcare services. Anyone telling you about waits anywhere outside of the US is flat out lying. It's because just one of those things that they've repeated enough that they think that they can get away with claiming it. It's utterly ridiculous. It's totally unfounded.
Every time someone says that, it's always based on the hope that no one will know how to talk to someone in those countries to confirm it. They say it about Canada and the UK, places known for poor healthcase, and they certainly don't have those problems. Places like central Europe (Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Switzerland) that lead the world in healthcare do NOT have those kinds of problems. Their healthcare is cheap and fantastic.
I was speaking to someone who is very well paid in the auto industry in Germany. It's the only reason I was willing to put it here.
-
@scottalanmiller said:
@Dashrender said:
@NetworkNerdWifey said:
Also I think someone asked about the tax thing - yes, we are covered as far as not having to pay the penalty tax. HCSN are allowed under ACA. We have a tax form that we will submit at tax time.
Not worried about the penalty tax... Concerned about the you getting money and not paying taxes on it. Here in Nebraska (and maybe this is federal) you have to report all sources of income. Technically this would be a source of income I would think - but perhaps it's not -it's just so darned weird...
You don't consider NORMAL insurance to be a form of income, right?
yeah, that is why I put the 'so darned weird' part in there...
-
@scottalanmiller said:
@Dashrender said:
@MattSpeller said:
http://www.ees-financial.com/calculators/TakeHomePayCalculator.htm
Those tax rates (not counting deductions) seem very similar to US tax rates.
Most countries that give free healthcare have taxes relatively similar to the US (if you don't count healthcare cost as a tax, which it is.) If you include mandatory taxes like your health insurance, the US has some of the highest taxes in the world. They keep calling healthcare "insurance" rather than a "tax" to hide how high the taxes are.
That's absolutely true assuming the rest of the setup is as described.
