Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
I believe they are an outgrowth of human inefficiency, government bureaucracy, and people trying to protect their jobs from automation. Just to sum up my points.
Sure, but that's basically the same thing. As long as we don't have GBI, we have a strong incentive to have all of those things. Inefficiency is rewarded, bureaucracy is rewarded, protecting jobs is needed. Since GBI is a choice the choice to not have it is a design for those things.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@scottalanmiller said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Here we are, moved the GBI discussion out here.
So are we talking about GBI? My main point was it was obvious that the author looks down on blue collar jobs, why else would you call them shit jobs? I agree there are useless jobs. I don't agree that there are people that actively work to create these jobs to keep people from being idle. I believe they are an outgrowth of human inefficiency, government bureaucracy, and people trying to protect their jobs from automation. Just to sum up my points.
So what I want to know is this and I am trying to approach GBI with an open mind so these are my genuine questions.
1.) If everyone has GBI, do other government benefits go away? Food stamps, SNAP, etc since you should have the money to buy food and basic needs?
2.) where does the money come from? The government gets it money from taxing. People's income, sale's tax, etc. If someone works are they excluded from GBI? Is your GBI taxed? Are they taxed higher than those of GBI in order to pay for GBI.
3.) On a philosophical note, does the government not control you once they give you a GBI?
4.) Also what about child support? Considering the government is now giving you income for your basic needs and I would assume your children, child support wouldn't be needed after a divorce.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@scottalanmiller said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Here we are, moved the GBI discussion out here.
So are we talking about GBI? My main point was it was obvious that the author looks down on blue collar jobs, why else would you call them shit jobs? I agree there are useless jobs. I don't agree that there are people that actively work to create these jobs to keep people from being idle. I believe they are an outgrowth of human inefficiency, government bureaucracy, and people trying to protect their jobs from automation. Just to sum up my points.
So what I want to know is this and I am trying to approach GBI with an open mind so these are my genuine questions.
1.) If everyone has GBI, do other government benefits go away? Food stamps, SNAP, etc since you should have the money to buy food and basic needs?
2.) where does the money come from? The government gets it money from taxing. People's income, sale's tax, etc. If someone works are they excluded from GBI? Is your GBI taxed? Are they taxed higher than those of GBI in order to pay for GBI.
3.) On a philosophical note, does the government not control you once they give you a GBI?
4.) Also what about child support? Considering the government is now giving you income for your basic needs and I would assume your children, child support wouldn't be needed after a divorce.
Correct, all of that type of stuff would be unnecessary. And part of the positives there are that the handing out of money is EASY. Takes like no effort to get people their money.
-
Yeah this post proves he doens't understand the entire concept of GBI
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
1.) If everyone has GBI, do other government benefits go away? Food stamps, SNAP, etc since you should have the money to buy food and basic needs?
2.) where does the money come from? The government gets it money from taxing. People's income, sale's tax, etc. If someone works are they excluded from GBI? Is your GBI taxed? Are they taxed higher than those of GBI in order to pay for GBI.
3.) On a philosophical note, does the government not control you once they give you a GBI?
-
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Yeah this post proves he doens't understand the entire concept of GBI
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
1.) If everyone has GBI, do other government benefits go away? Food stamps, SNAP, etc since you should have the money to buy food and basic needs?
2.) where does the money come from? The government gets it money from taxing. People's income, sale's tax, etc. If someone works are they excluded from GBI? Is your GBI taxed? Are they taxed higher than those of GBI in order to pay for GBI.
3.) On a philosophical note, does the government not control you once they give you a GBI?
There are different competing theories to GBI.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
1.) If everyone has GBI, do other government benefits go away? Food stamps, SNAP, etc since you should have the money to buy food and basic needs?
Right, all of these programs would be unnecessary. Because no one would qualify. Everyone has enough money for basic needs like food and shelter.
And without loads of cost to oversee those programs, you save a fortune in doing this, too.
-
Still wondering where the money comes from.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
3.) On a philosophical note, does the government not control you once they give you a GBI?
No, far less. Because today, government money is discretionary. But with GBI, it is not, it is guaranteed. So it is specifically removing the government from a lot of potential meddling.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
/sigh
FFS, the same place it does now.
No one has ever stated that no one would work. That would be species stagnation.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
2.) where does the money come from? The government gets it money from taxing. People's income, sale's tax, etc. If someone works are they excluded from GBI? Is your GBI taxed? Are they taxed higher than those of GBI in order to pay for GBI.
No magic here. Where does the money come from today? GBI theory says that LESS money is needed, not more. You never tax government pay, makes no sense.
So there is no need for as much money as there is today. You reduce the total government financial needs. Then you take discretionary income (that above GBI) potentially, tax property, tax sales, tax business. Basically, other than simplifying tax laws just to be practical, taxes don't really need to change.
That's the magic of GBI, there is really no need for the money to "come from somewhere". We already have a surplus.
-
Part of the goal of GBI is to grow, not shrink the economy, while lowering the overhead.
Think of any company becoming more lean and efficient. Spend less, earn more.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
By taxing corporations that make billions and maybe pay a few million in taxes, by taxing the positions that can't go away (at an appropriate amount).
From the same taxing methods used today, but no you can't tax GBI because then you're defeating the point of it. I already asked this, and was answered on it. really it was more a NYS complaint
-
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
/sigh
FFS, the same place it does now.
No one has ever stated that no one would work. That would be species stagnation.
I am sorry that I want details, before I get on a bandwagon to totally change my ideas and how things have worked in my country since my country was founded.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
/sigh
FFS, the same place it does now.
No one has ever stated that no one would work. That would be species stagnation.
I am sorry that I want details, before I get on a bandwagon to totally change my ideas and how things have worked in my country since well my country was founded.
Worked well in this country? Bullshit.
-
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
/sigh
FFS, the same place it does now.
No one has ever stated that no one would work. That would be species stagnation.
I am sorry that I want details, before I get on a bandwagon to totally change my ideas and how things have worked in my country since well my country was founded.
Worked well in this country? Bullshit.
He didn't say that. He was pausing for effect.
Since... well since the country was founded.
-
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
/sigh
FFS, the same place it does now.
No one has ever stated that no one would work. That would be species stagnation.
I am sorry that I want details, before I get on a bandwagon to totally change my ideas and how things have worked in my country since well my country was founded.
Worked well in this country? Bullshit.
that was a typo.
-
They might have worded poorly since it was founded, so it COULD be worded as...
They've worked poorly since, well... since the country was founded.
-
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@jaredbusch said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
@penguinwrangler said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Still wondering where the money comes from.
/sigh
FFS, the same place it does now.
No one has ever stated that no one would work. That would be species stagnation.
I am sorry that I want details, before I get on a bandwagon to totally change my ideas and how things have worked in my country since well my country was founded.
Worked well in this country? Bullshit.
that was a typo.
Ok.
-
Jobs such as editorial services, could disappear and never be needed again. So long as your software was proficient enough with the language to understand the nuances.
-
@dustinb3403 said in Discussing Basic Income from Forbes Article:
Jobs such as editorial services, could disappear and never be needed again. So long as your software was proficient enough with the language to understand the nuances.
That's a tough one, but potential someday. Grammarly isn't cutting it today for that, though.
