GDPR Resources
-
This link was posted over on another forum just today --
https://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/ -
@danp said in GDPR Resources:
This link was posted over on another forum just today --
https://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/Thanks for actually replying to the thread topic @Danp. I'm not really sure what to do with this experience...
-
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@danp said in GDPR Resources:
This link was posted over on another forum just today --
https://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/Thanks for actually replying to the thread topic @Danp. I'm not really sure what to do with this experience...
Hey, I was supporting you
-
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Your average US based website is under no obligation to do anything for the GDPR, but US based websites are something like 90% of the coverage cases.
So I should setup a Datacenter in post-brexit UK so I have low latency to the EU, but can ignore GDPR?
-
@storageninja said in GDPR Resources:
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Your average US based website is under no obligation to do anything for the GDPR, but US based websites are something like 90% of the coverage cases.
So I should setup a Datacenter in post-brexit UK so I have low latency to the EU, but can ignore GDPR?
Or you could just put a cheap one inches outside the EU anywhere, if that's your goal. UK is in the EU so will already have adopted the GDPR prior to leaving.
-
@storageninja said in GDPR Resources:
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Your average US based website is under no obligation to do anything for the GDPR, but US based websites are something like 90% of the coverage cases.
So I should setup a Datacenter in post-brexit UK so I have low latency to the EU, but can ignore GDPR?
It's not a matter of ignoring the GDPR. It's it not existing to you if you are not in the EU. Same as we "ignore" all EU laws outside of the EU.
-
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
@storageninja said in GDPR Resources:
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Your average US based website is under no obligation to do anything for the GDPR, but US based websites are something like 90% of the coverage cases.
So I should setup a Datacenter in post-brexit UK so I have low latency to the EU, but can ignore GDPR?
Or you could just put a cheap one inches outside the EU anywhere, if that's your goal. UK is in the EU so will already have adopted the GDPR prior to leaving.
What part of post-brexit is hard to understand?
-
Think of it like the US freedom of speech. Russians can't cite the US freedom of speech law as protecting them in Russia, just because they were "talking to an American." It's not a Russian law.
-
@jaredbusch said in GDPR Resources:
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
@storageninja said in GDPR Resources:
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Your average US based website is under no obligation to do anything for the GDPR, but US based websites are something like 90% of the coverage cases.
So I should setup a Datacenter in post-brexit UK so I have low latency to the EU, but can ignore GDPR?
Or you could just put a cheap one inches outside the EU anywhere, if that's your goal. UK is in the EU so will already have adopted the GDPR prior to leaving.
What part of post-brexit is hard to understand?
Just because it is post Brexit doesn't mean that pre-Brexit laws stop existing. EU laws, like this one, are already adopted pre-Brexit. If the UK REJECTS the law post-Brexit, that's different. But they'd have to remove it, having already adopted it.
-
The UK has covered this already in their Brexit talks. EU laws are not just adopted at the EU level, individual states have to adopt them themselves as part of the process. So in leaving the EU, all those laws are still there in the UK. Of course, we totally expect the UK to run through them and change a lot of them. But the UK was teh leader in writing a lot of them, so a lot will likely be kept anyway. But being post-Brexit doesn't imply anything about an assumed change in laws later. Only that the UK has the power to decide on them, but they have to remove them since they will already exist.
-
Now, I assume, that the wording of the law might only state that EU citizens are covered. So in Brexiting, UK citizens might end up, depending on the wording, being legally repsonsible to protect EU citizens, without being covered themselves.
-
Also to circle back on what you ignored earlier.
Treaties and pacts can and do force other countries to accept and enforce things from other countries.
The most common one to come to mind is the Berne Convention (copyright stuff).
-
@jaredbusch said in GDPR Resources:
Also to circle back on what you ignored earlier.
Treaties and pacts can and do force other countries to accept and enforce things form other countries.
The most common one to come to mind is the Berne Convention (copyright stuff).
Of course they can, I never said anything to the contrary. But they must exist for there to be enforcement. Right now, the US doesn't have any known treaty that does anything like this, and would be very unlikely to because this is a new, unanticipated situation.
Given the nature of the GDPR, it would be extremely hard for earlier treaties to cover it. Now, new treaties might easily address it and add it broadly around the world. That's to be expected. But until that happens, which is the "new laws being made" that I've been mentioning, it's not applicable.
-
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Now, I assume, that the wording of the law might only state that EU citizens are covered. So in Brexiting, UK citizens might end up, depending on the wording, being legally repsonsible to protect EU citizens, without being covered themselves.
Under the terms of the EU compact, the UK is creating a law based on GDPR as are all EU member countries. Unless repealed UK businesses will have to effectively comply with GDPR.
-
@jaredbusch said in GDPR Resources:
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@danp said in GDPR Resources:
This link was posted over on another forum just today --
https://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/Thanks for actually replying to the thread topic @Danp. I'm not really sure what to do with this experience...
Hey, I was supporting you
You have been. It was more that @Danp was on topic. We've both followed @scottalanmiller into his overall derailment.
-
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
Now, I assume, that the wording of the law might only state that EU citizens are covered. So in Brexiting, UK citizens might end up, depending on the wording, being legally repsonsible to protect EU citizens, without being covered themselves.
Under the terms of the EU compact, the UK is creating a law based on GDPR as are all EU member countries. Unless repealed UK businesses will have to effectively comply with GDPR.
Exactly. And I doubt that they will repeal.
-
There is some thought that the US-EU Privacy Shield. might bring the GDPR to the US. But it is very unclear if this is true.
-
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@jaredbusch said in GDPR Resources:
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@danp said in GDPR Resources:
This link was posted over on another forum just today --
https://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/Thanks for actually replying to the thread topic @Danp. I'm not really sure what to do with this experience...
Hey, I was supporting you
You have been. It was more that @Danp was on topic. We've both followed @scottalanmiller into his overall derailment.
Hardly a derailment, it's the core of the conversation. Outside of the EU, how does the GDPR affect you? It's totally by what local laws (sometimes in the form of treaties) present it to you locally.
-
It worth noting that even if the US-EU Privacy Shield would have made the GDPR possible int he US, Executive Order 13768 may have removed it. The order appears to make the GDPR impossible to implement in the US without further action regardless of existing treaties.
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/01/30/trump_executive_order_public_safety_privacy_shield/
-
@scottalanmiller said in GDPR Resources:
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@jaredbusch said in GDPR Resources:
@kelly said in GDPR Resources:
@danp said in GDPR Resources:
This link was posted over on another forum just today --
https://techblog.bozho.net/gdpr-practical-guide-developers/Thanks for actually replying to the thread topic @Danp. I'm not really sure what to do with this experience...
Hey, I was supporting you
You have been. It was more that @Danp was on topic. We've both followed @scottalanmiller into his overall derailment.
Hardly a derailment, it's the core of the conversation. Outside of the EU, how does the GDPR affect you? It's totally by what local laws (sometimes in the form of treaties) present it to you locally.
It is the core of a conversation around GDPR, but not core to the question as asked. I'm not objecting to the conversation, finding it amusing how little time has been spent on the original question.
