If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one
-
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
If you have a client that implements SMTP, you are all set. But without that, postfix is needed (or something) that adds SMTP capabilities.
SMTP can be sent via telnet. Nothing special is required of a system to send email.
If it can be sent via telnet, can it be sent by ssh?
-
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
If you have a client that implements SMTP, you are all set. But without that, postfix is needed (or something) that adds SMTP capabilities.
SMTP can be sent via telnet. Nothing special is required of a system to send email.
That's not how it works. The application still has to have SMTP in the app in order to send. The mail command, the one installed by mailx, does not have SMTP in it and just drops a file locally into the MTA's processing queue.
So for what @BRRABill was asking and demonstrating, yes an MTA like postfix is needed on each system. If you have a different email client than he and I were discussing that handles SMTP for you, then obviously you don't need that.
-
@nerdydad said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
If you have a client that implements SMTP, you are all set. But without that, postfix is needed (or something) that adds SMTP capabilities.
SMTP can be sent via telnet. Nothing special is required of a system to send email.
If it can be sent via telnet, can it be sent by ssh?
This is getting really confusing. No, that's not how it works. Telnet is just a raw connection. SMTP is the protocol. Anything trying to send via it must implement the protocol. You can do HTTP over telnet, too, but that doesn't make it telnet, you still have to use HTTP.
-
@nerdydad said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
If you have a client that implements SMTP, you are all set. But without that, postfix is needed (or something) that adds SMTP capabilities.
SMTP can be sent via telnet. Nothing special is required of a system to send email.
If it can be sent via telnet, can it be sent by ssh?
SMTP has no encrypted connection handling, so no. The payload can be encrypted once the SMTP connection is established (STARTTLS), but SMTP has no encryption prior to that.
-
My root issue, I guess, if that I cannot get dnf-automatic to send e-mail to any public e-mail servers. Not Office365, for example.
Can I get it to send to my internal e-mail server on my internal network? Sure.
-
@tim_g said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
Yeah, didn't see this thread before posting this: https://mangolassi.it/topic/15899/basic-email-sending-with-linux/9
If your email is hosted through somewhere else, such as O365, you'll need to edit your SPF record to allow emails from that server or use an SMTP server that authenticates with and relays to O365.
DNF-Automatic, for example, from what I've seen, does not have SMTP authentication options. So I've been using an SMTP server.
SPF is optional and loads of email services either don't care or only prefer it. It's good, but it's not part of base SMTP and not required for email to be "working". Like many things, like MX, SPF, and PTR records, many services either demand them or encourage them, but they are extra, optional security checks to reduce the chance of spam and are a totally different topic - one of convincing third parties that you are not a spammer, which is not the same at all as the system level task of sending email out.
-
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@nerdydad said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
If you have a client that implements SMTP, you are all set. But without that, postfix is needed (or something) that adds SMTP capabilities.
SMTP can be sent via telnet. Nothing special is required of a system to send email.
If it can be sent via telnet, can it be sent by ssh?
SMTP has no encrypted connection handling, so no. The payload can be encrypted once the SMTP connection is established (STARTTLS), but SMTP has no encryption prior to that.
If you sent over SSH, though, it would. You actually get. Given that you used the telnet example, and use that connection methodology to say that you can send over telnet, you can actually do that over SSH, too. It's really silly, but if you are running the SMTP protocol manually then it works over SSH just like over telnet.
-
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@tim_g said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
Yeah, didn't see this thread before posting this: https://mangolassi.it/topic/15899/basic-email-sending-with-linux/9
If your email is hosted through somewhere else, such as O365, you'll need to edit your SPF record to allow emails from that server or use an SMTP server that authenticates with and relays to O365.
DNF-Automatic, for example, from what I've seen, does not have SMTP authentication options. So I've been using an SMTP server.
SPF is optional and loads of email services either don't care or only prefer it. It's good, but it's not part of base SMTP and not required for email to be "working". Like many things, like MX, SPF, and PTR records, many services either demand them or encourage them, but they are extra, optional security checks to reduce the chance of spam and are a totally different topic - one of convincing third parties that you are not a spammer, which is not the same at all as the system level task of sending email out.
While all 100% true, they are required if you want the mail your are sending with the system out to be received in today's world.
-
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
My root issue, I guess, if that I cannot get dnf-automatic to send e-mail to any public e-mail servers. Not Office365, for example.
Can I get it to send to my internal e-mail server on my internal network? Sure.
This is very different from what you asked. You asked about getting email working from the OS, and the OS does it with postfix and the standard mail command that you were trying to use depends on an MTA. Other applications may have their own SMTP individually. But that is a question about an application sending email, not about Linux or the OS sending it. Totally different concepts.
-
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@tim_g said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
Yeah, didn't see this thread before posting this: https://mangolassi.it/topic/15899/basic-email-sending-with-linux/9
If your email is hosted through somewhere else, such as O365, you'll need to edit your SPF record to allow emails from that server or use an SMTP server that authenticates with and relays to O365.
DNF-Automatic, for example, from what I've seen, does not have SMTP authentication options. So I've been using an SMTP server.
SPF is optional and loads of email services either don't care or only prefer it. It's good, but it's not part of base SMTP and not required for email to be "working". Like many things, like MX, SPF, and PTR records, many services either demand them or encourage them, but they are extra, optional security checks to reduce the chance of spam and are a totally different topic - one of convincing third parties that you are not a spammer, which is not the same at all as the system level task of sending email out.
While all 100% true, they are required if you want the mail your are sending with the system out to be received in today's world.
Most people sending emails from servers are sending to themselves, not in general. So even in the "real world", this almost never applies. I certainly don't have any use for it on my systems.
-
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
My root issue, I guess, if that I cannot get dnf-automatic to send e-mail to any public e-mail servers. Not Office365, for example.
Can I get it to send to my internal e-mail server on my internal network? Sure.
This is very different from what you asked. You asked about getting email working from the OS, and the OS does it with postfix and the standard mail command that you were trying to use depends on an MTA. Other applications may have their own SMTP individually. But that is a question about an application sending email, not about Linux or the OS sending it. Totally different concepts.
I told you that oyu gave the corect answer on an incorrectly worded question.
-
@scottalanmiller said
This is very different from what you asked. You asked about getting email working from the OS, and the OS does it with postfix and the standard mail command that you were trying to use depends on an MTA. Other applications may have their own SMTP individually. But that is a question about an application sending email, not about Linux or the OS sending it. Totally different concepts.
It is, but like everything here at ML the original question got critiqued and then spun into a new thread.
-
@jaredbusch said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
My root issue, I guess, if that I cannot get dnf-automatic to send e-mail to any public e-mail servers. Not Office365, for example.
Can I get it to send to my internal e-mail server on my internal network? Sure.
This is very different from what you asked. You asked about getting email working from the OS, and the OS does it with postfix and the standard mail command that you were trying to use depends on an MTA. Other applications may have their own SMTP individually. But that is a question about an application sending email, not about Linux or the OS sending it. Totally different concepts.
I told you that oyu gave the corect answer on an incorrectly worded question.
Right, which I've been trying to explain to him offline. He asked you one thing privately and me a different thing. Me, he asked about the mail command and getting the OS to send.
-
@jaredbusch said
I told you that oyu gave the corect answer on an incorrectly worded question.
And how was it incorrectly worded?
-
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@jaredbusch said
I told you that oyu gave the corect answer on an incorrectly worded question.
And how was it incorrectly worded?
oh FFS
-
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@scottalanmiller said
This is very different from what you asked. You asked about getting email working from the OS, and the OS does it with postfix and the standard mail command that you were trying to use depends on an MTA. Other applications may have their own SMTP individually. But that is a question about an application sending email, not about Linux or the OS sending it. Totally different concepts.
It is, but like everything here at ML the original question got critiqued and then spun into a new thread.
But it is a totally new topic. You should ask that in a new thread. As it is not directly related to the topics discussed.
THink of it this way....
Windows can't send email as Windows. But Thunderbird on Windows can send SMTP itself. Just because an app brings a capability doesn't mean that the OS has that capability.
-
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
@jaredbusch said
I told you that oyu gave the corect answer on an incorrectly worded question.
And how was it incorrectly worded?
Did you want to know about Fedora sending email or dnf-automatic sending email?
Fedora is what was asked about.
-
OK, so let's take this a step back.
Bob is an IT admin. He hosts his mail on Office365.
He wants to use dnf-automatic to send mail.
How does he do this?
-
@brrabill said in If you have multiple servers on a network, do you install postfix on each one:
My root issue, I guess, if that I cannot get dnf-automatic to send e-mail to any public e-mail servers. Not Office365, for example.
This is because Office365, Google, etc email does not accept and send out emails for just any random email server.
They require authentication.
This is why you need to use, in the case of dnf-automatic, an SMTP server that is set up and authenticated with Office365. That way when dnf-automatic sends out an email as you@domain.com, it goes to your SMTP server to authenticate, then sends via whatever account info the SMTP server is authenticating by... whether it's a global "relay@domain.com" address or whatever.
-
@tim_g said
This is because Office365, Google, etc email does not accept and send out emails for just any random email server.
They require authentication.
This is why you need to use, in the case of dnf-automatic, an SMTP server that is set up and authenticated with Office365. That way when dnf-automatic sends out an email as you@domain.com, it goes to your SMTP server to authenticate, then sends via whatever account info the SMTP server is authenticating by... whether it's a global "relay@domain.com" address or whatever.
This is what I am contending. That just entering a SMTP server in dnf-automatic will not get the job done. Unless you own it and can control it. Or use some sort of authentication.
However, postfix does seem to work to Office365, and GMail. No questions asked.
