I can't even begin to explain this question
-
Yes our phones and internet are supplied by the same provider, which is why the question came up.
-
So you have two lines
ISP
- 1: Phone
- 2: WAN
?
-
The question it's self kind of throws me for a loop, as phone service requires almost no bandwidth at all. Even if we combined all of our lines together the summary bandwidth they'd offer is maybe 2MBps.
-
That is not how any of this works.
-
@dustinb3403 said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
The question it's self kind of throws me for a loop, as phone service requires almost no bandwidth at all. Even if we combined all of our lines together the summary bandwidth they'd offer is maybe 2MBps.
Agreed - with SIP, at least as I understand... there is no need to have two lines - ever. Unless you have two separate ISP so you have redundant service.
But that is not what you (they) have is it....
-
@jaredbusch said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
That is not how any of this works.
That's my point, and I'm at a loss on how to explain it. I felt like a deer in headlights when the question was asked.
Because no one would rightfully ask the question unless they were intentionally being a roadblock.
-
@dustinb3403 said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
Is it possible to take the bandwidth from our digital telephone (non-sip) lines and have that amount supplied to our internet performance, so we can port the numbers and have faster internet?
Sounds really like they are trying to take 1980's technology (ISDN type) and bond them into one line.... in this age,.. pointless, useless and a complete waste of money and time.
-
We have phone and internet on separate lines.
We have a block of DID's.
The question asked can we take the bandwidth provided by our phone lines (cumulative DID bandwidth allocation) and have that supplied to out internet performance to have more bandwidth.
At least that is how I interpreted the question.
-
Just stop making calls, Internet bandwidth frees right up.
-
I totally understand why they ask this question. They don't understand how little bandwidth phone calls use.
The fact that you have digital in-house phones isn't relevant. The connection to the PSTN is the only thing that matters. And - as you said, it would amount to about 2 Mb/s.Draw them a picture. Huge pipe on the internet side, and tiny pipe on the SIP trunk side. Show them how it would make no difference at all.
-
@scottalanmiller said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
Just stop making calls, Internet bandwidth frees right up.
Separate lines. so no it does not.
-
@dashrender said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
I totally understand why they ask this question. They don't understand how little bandwidth phone calls use.
The fact that you have digital in-house phones isn't relevant. The connection to the PSTN is the only thing that matters. And - as you said, it would amount to about 2 Mb/s.Draw them a picture. Huge pipe on the internet side, and tiny pipe on the SIP trunk side. Show them how it would make no difference at all.
Not true, of course making hte internet pipe larger would make a difference. it would make it faster. even by a little.
-
@jaredbusch said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
@scottalanmiller said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
Just stop making calls, Internet bandwidth frees right up.
Separate lines. so no it does not.
Exactly.
My bosses choice has me in the same boat - ISP is one line, a completely separate line exists for the SIP trunks.
-
Which really the question should be, hey ISP (and phone provider) what would it take to increase our internet pipe?
Not this horseshit question of lets take the bandwidth provided by the phones and some how bump the internet performance up.
It's such a trivial amount of performance that it just doesn't make sense.
-
@jaredbusch said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
@dashrender said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
I totally understand why they ask this question. They don't understand how little bandwidth phone calls use.
The fact that you have digital in-house phones isn't relevant. The connection to the PSTN is the only thing that matters. And - as you said, it would amount to about 2 Mb/s.Draw them a picture. Huge pipe on the internet side, and tiny pipe on the SIP trunk side. Show them how it would make no difference at all.
Not true, of course making hte internet pipe larger would make a difference. it would make it faster. even by a little.
OK, now you're pulling a Scott (yes it's a think
) - and of course you're right, but will they notice the difference of an extra .5 - 2 Mb/s of bandwidth? Very unlikely. -
@dashrender said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
@jaredbusch said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
@scottalanmiller said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
Just stop making calls, Internet bandwidth frees right up.
Separate lines. so no it does not.
Exactly.
My bosses choice has me in the same boat - ISP is one line, a completely separate line exists for the SIP trunks.
some details he may not understand... he's pissing money.
Kill the split, up the one. If they are the same ISP, then you don't have any redundancy with it.... so why have it. SIP uses so little over head,... and by expanding your pipe,... you solve the problem
-
Dustin,
You explain that you can easily call the ISP and ask that the internet line speed be increased from XX to YY.
Then you can also say that you can add traffic shaping rules to the internet line to make sure availability is reserved for phone calls.
But the ISP will not guarantee the call quality in that scenario like they do in your current scenario.
-
@jaredbusch said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
That is not how any of this works.
You can't keep saying that without posting an appropriate meme. I think that is an internet foul.
-
@dustinb3403 said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
Which really the question should be, hey ISP (and phone provider) what would it take to increase our internet pipe?
Not this horseshit question of lets take the bandwidth provided by the phones and some how bump the internet performance up.
It's such a trivial amount of performance that it just doesn't make sense.
What's interesting to me is - why do they know it's on a separate pipe? Them knowing this lead to them asking, of course they probably think the SIP pipe is the same speed as the ISP pipe, hence the question.
-
@brrabill said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
@jaredbusch said in I can't even begin to explain this question:
That is not how any of this works.
You can't keep saying that without posting an appropriate meme. I think that is an internet foul.
