Additional domain controller in remote site
-
when i run nslookup in any branch computer, it resolve successfully but it use the main DNS even if i they have as primary DNS the ADC ip address
what anger me is that machines in the branch office neglect the ADC -
@IT-ADMIN said:
when i run nslookup in any branch computer, it resolve successfully but it use the main DNS even if i they have as primary DNS the ADC ip address
what anger me is that machines in the branch office neglect the ADCWhat happens when you force nslookup to use the branch server?
-
@Dashrender said:
what server is providing DHCP for the branch PCs?
Again, what server is providing DHCP to the branch PCs? Is the scope set correctly to give the PC's the DNS of the branch DNS server.
-
@alexntg said:
@IT-ADMIN said:
when i run nslookup in any branch computer, it resolve successfully but it use the main DNS even if i they have as primary DNS the ADC ip address
what anger me is that machines in the branch office neglect the ADCWhat happens when you force nslookup to use the branch server?
really i didn't try that, but tomorrow i will go to the branch office and try this, thank you
-
@IT-ADMIN said:
@alexntg said:
@IT-ADMIN said:
when i run nslookup in any branch computer, it resolve successfully but it use the main DNS even if i they have as primary DNS the ADC ip address
what anger me is that machines in the branch office neglect the ADCWhat happens when you force nslookup to use the branch server?
really i didn't try that, but tomorrow i will go to the branch office and try this, thank you
You can try it from your computer, even. Just force nslookup to use the branch DC.
-
@Dashrender said:
@Dashrender said:
what server is providing DHCP for the branch PCs?
Again, what server is providing DHCP to the branch PCs? Is the scope set correctly to give the PC's the DNS of the branch DNS server.
yes, the DHCP is providing the correct DNS setting which is the ip of my ADC as primary DNS and the internet gateway as secondary DNS
-
@IT-ADMIN said:
@Dashrender said:
@Dashrender said:
what server is providing DHCP for the branch PCs?
Again, what server is providing DHCP to the branch PCs? Is the scope set correctly to give the PC's the DNS of the branch DNS server.
yes, the DHCP is providing the correct DNS setting which is the ip of my ADC as primary DNS and the internet gateway as secondary DNS
For the branch site, the DC should be primary DNS, and the DC at your main location should be secondary. Non-AD DNS sources should not be used.
-
@IT-ADMIN said:
@Dashrender said:
@Dashrender said:
what server is providing DHCP for the branch PCs?
Again, what server is providing DHCP to the branch PCs? Is the scope set correctly to give the PC's the DNS of the branch DNS server.
yes, the DHCP is providing the correct DNS setting which is the ip of my ADC as primary DNS and the internet gateway as secondary DNS
Internet gateway? No it must be the other DC.
-
@alexntg said:
@IT-ADMIN said:
@Dashrender said:
@Dashrender said:
what server is providing DHCP for the branch PCs?
Again, what server is providing DHCP to the branch PCs? Is the scope set correctly to give the PC's the DNS of the branch DNS server.
yes, the DHCP is providing the correct DNS setting which is the ip of my ADC as primary DNS and the internet gateway as secondary DNS
For the branch site, the DC should be primary DNS, and the DC at your main location should be secondary. Non-AD DNS sources should not be used.
I use them but only for tertiary and quaternary DNS options and only when I have only two DCs.
-
We use a 5 DCs at our main office and branches have no DCs. Since I use PDQ for package deployment and I use a separate Group Policy for each branch. I have never had an issue with our T1 Connections. You can use AD Sites and Services to create a new site for the branch and just build the second DC at your main office. I really don't see why you need a second DC at the branch, user authentication and group policy don't use much bandwidth at all. I bet your branch users are still accessing their shares and applications over the WAN. Which uses much more resources than AD would ever use.
-
We use central AD only as well.
-
@scottalanmiller said:
@alexntg said:
@IT-ADMIN said:
@Dashrender said:
@Dashrender said:
what server is providing DHCP for the branch PCs?
Again, what server is providing DHCP to the branch PCs? Is the scope set correctly to give the PC's the DNS of the branch DNS server.
yes, the DHCP is providing the correct DNS setting which is the ip of my ADC as primary DNS and the internet gateway as secondary DNS
For the branch site, the DC should be primary DNS, and the DC at your main location should be secondary. Non-AD DNS sources should not be used.
I use them but only for tertiary and quaternary DNS options and only when I have only two DCs.
Using non-AD DNS in an AD enviornment can lead to kerberos errors and other fun, erratic behavior.
-
Yes. Using non-AD DNS is a more expert option. Just going to make things harder. Stick with integrated AD / DNS.
-
@scottalanmiller said:
Yes. Using non-AD DNS is a more expert option. Just going to make things harder. Stick with integrated AD / DNS.
yes of course i set my ADC to be DNS server, i think that this issue have no solution because i think i have everything set correctly whether it be physical and logial,
i will bring that ADC from the branch office and content myself with only one DC in the main office. -
Two in the main office is good.
-
Have you tried forcing a lookup against the branch DC via nslookup yet?
-
can you imagine what happen to me yesterday night??
i was trying to solve the problem, i added one reverse lookup zone for the remote network 192.168.5 because there was only one reverse lookup zone for the main network, after doing so the main DC get crazy, a message appears "THE DNS SERVER NOT OPERATING", fortunately i do that at night and no employee was there, everything stack, no logon server available, the network drive is not working....
i had very difficult time, i realize the importance of the DNS, so i delete the reverse lookup zone, then the DNS came to life, i restarted the main DC, the same issue again DNS NOT OPERATING, i doubt the remote DC have some affect on the main DC so i disable the VPN, restarted the main DC, DNS came to life, i enable the VPN, the DNS stack, that time i realize that the remote DC who is responsible of all of this, so i remove this shit from the Domain and from the Site and services console, everything is working now ,lol -
Wow. Glad that you found that.
-
so you only have one DNS server running now?
-
@Dashrender said:
so you only have one DNS server running now?
yes, i content myself with only one DC - DNS server which is the old one in the main office, and users in the branch office login from the main DC, hopefully the remote login will not consume much bandwidth since i have only 512 Kbps speed, i wanted to have a remote DC from my branch computers but unfortunately this project was not successful and may corrupt the all domain because the DNS service is everything in the domain, if corrupted or damaged, it will be a total lost, fortunately i test that at night otherwise i will be in trouble with the management
