Don't Stay in School
-
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
@Minion-Queen said in Don't Stay in School:
Practical life skills: Balancing a check book, first aid, running a house (paying bills, cooking, etc). Teach them to really research online.
Nice list - I was thinking of the cooking thing - If memory servs (and it doesn't always) Scott mentioned that home ec was on his waste of time list. I never took home ec - it was definitely considered a class for girls - but this class actually sounds like what really needs to be taught, to everyone. It should include the things you mentioned - balancing a check book, first aid, running a house (Love this one! - and yard care should be brought into this, and house/apt maintenance), and car maintenance too. Everyone should be able to do basic troubleshooting of car issues.
In NY home economics doesn't do what the name suggests. At least not any more, to the anger of my home economics teacher. When she started out it was more of a life skills class. How to plan meals, balance a check book, clean (a huge skill that is really never taught you just kind of pick it up), do basic clothes patching, etc.
When I was in school, the year she retired, it was a sew this animal with a stitch that doesn't make sense for clothes and here is how to cook stuff. We never really got into meal planning or the actual economics of a house.
-
I actually wound up in Home Ec. It actually was a great class. We did cooking, and etiquette for when eating at the fancy diners (which helps if you want to get jobs in that field), and we held group discussions in a "formal" home dinner type situation. It was surprisingly a lot of fun. There were more than just one or two guys in there. A lot of the class felt like busy work because there's only so many ways you can burn a biscuit.
It was at that point I actually took an interest in cooking. I enjoy trying new things, as does my wife. It's been fun, for the most part... except when we make Ewwwww meals, lol. Looking back, that's one of the things I would do again.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
The one thing that the author leaves out, probably because he's 22 and never really thought about it, is that the school system is actually mostly a babysitting system and cover for the welfare programs.
Did you only skim the videos? This was specifically mentioned.
-
@art_of_shred said in Don't Stay in School:
You certainly can't put much stock in a lot of what kids say, as it's mostly driven by immature emotion and selfishness, but pretty much any school-age child has asked "Why do I need to learn this? How is this going to be applicable to my life in any way as an adult?" If it's obvious enough for nearly all children to have picked up on, then there is an agenda driving it. Call it a conspiracy, or whatever. The organized education system, at least in the West, is a sham.
Even moreso than "kids recognize it" the really telling thing is that teachers can't explain why they have to teach it.
-
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
Interesting. Though what's wrong with public baby sitting service? Why not really do it right and go that way fully invest in that program - hell, I've always wondered why high school was more of a vocational school situation.
Because, I think that you will find, that vocational training is more costly to provide and harder to teach than what is broadly taught. Why pay for a skilled welder to teach a class that requires expensive gear and heavy insurance when you could make those kids sit in an extra English class with an otherwise unemployable teacher for half the price teaching from textbooks that never change and have no extra insurance or space needs?
-
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
I'll definitely agree that anything past probably 8th grade, and perhaps much less than that, are really needed by the common man.
Probably a mix. Few 8th graders are anywhere nearly prepared to talk politics. Things like geography and history are necessary for even basic functional citizenship (unless we remove democracy, then we don't have to educate every individual to all of these things - democracy comes at an incredible price.) Math needs to at least go to algebra. Science we go way, way too far. Computing we rarely even bother to introduce in any meaningful way. English lit... way too far.
I definitely understand where you are coming from - and I'll fully admit to my general lack of knowledge in history - but would dropping the general requirements for history really change much in the world we live in today?
Well, there is actually an issue that history is often mistaught in school so one could argue that it is not being taught at all today normally and that teaching it might have a ton of value. (See: "Lies My Teacher Told Me")
-
@dafyre said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
I'll definitely agree that anything past probably 8th grade, and perhaps much less than that, are really needed by the common man.
Probably a mix. Few 8th graders are anywhere nearly prepared to talk politics. Things like geography and history are necessary for even basic functional citizenship (unless we remove democracy, then we don't have to educate every individual to all of these things - democracy comes at an incredible price.) Math needs to at least go to algebra. Science we go way, way too far. Computing we rarely even bother to introduce in any meaningful way. English lit... way too far.
I definitely understand where you are coming from - and I'll fully admit to my general lack of knowledge in history - but would dropping the general requirements for history really change much in the world we live in today?
History gives us good examples of things that have been tried and worked, or things that have tried and failed... In technology, government, business...
And keeps us from being easily fooled by the media. Without a solid grasp of history, how does one put the world into a meaningful context? If the populace doesn't understand history, the populace cannot govern itself You can "let them" do so, but they lack the capability.
-
@coliver said in Don't Stay in School:
@Minion-Queen said in Don't Stay in School:
@dafyre said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
@dafyre said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
I'll definitely agree that anything past probably 8th grade, and perhaps much less than that, are really needed by the common man.
Probably a mix. Few 8th graders are anywhere nearly prepared to talk politics. Things like geography and history are necessary for even basic functional citizenship (unless we remove democracy, then we don't have to educate every individual to all of these things - democracy comes at an incredible price.) Math needs to at least go to algebra. Science we go way, way too far. Computing we rarely even bother to introduce in any meaningful way. English lit... way too far.
I definitely understand where you are coming from - and I'll fully admit to my general lack of knowledge in history - but would dropping the general requirements for history really change much in the world we live in today?
History gives us good examples of things that have been tried and worked, or things that have tried and failed... In technology, government, business...
of course - but do these lessons get learned by the masses today? At bare minimum, finding a way to improve delivery and retention of this knowledge is required.
If this were before the time of Google and online encyclopedias, I would agree with you. I think now, though, that teaching someone HOW to find that wealth of knowledge rather than making them retain it is better in some regards. Not that they should never be taught the history. But in the teaching, show them how to search for and learn from history.
According to my son this was one of the best things I taught him how to do: research on google.
One of my Grad professors told the class that 90% of a systems admin job was researching stuff via Google. If you couldn't research then you weren't cut out to work in IT.
Yeah, I don't believe that. I'd believe that 90% of people using that title don't know their jobs and research things on Google trying to make up for it. But as someone who has worked in systems administration a lot, you can't Google this stuff or you end up with the "Spiceworks Effect"... tons of people who don't understand the foundational knowledge and therefore can't figure out what to Google or can't interpret the Google answers. Google is a big part, sure. But 90%, hardly. 10%, maybe.
-
@Minion-Queen said in Don't Stay in School:
There is a reason that homeschooling is growing fast in the US. If you homeschool yes you have "required crap to teach" but if you are smart you hand your kid the book and say read it fast.
That's a state by state thing. Not a federal requirement. Texas gives us zero crap to teach.
-
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
@Minion-Queen said in Don't Stay in School:
There is a reason that homeschooling is growing fast in the US. If you homeschool yes you have "required crap to teach" but if you are smart you hand your kid the book and say read it fast.
Unless there is a standardized test that they are taking that proves they learned that knowledge, what's the point? Other than learning for learning sake of course.
Because learning for learning sake is a very, very good thing.
-
@JaredBusch said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
The one thing that the author leaves out, probably because he's 22 and never really thought about it, is that the school system is actually mostly a babysitting system and cover for the welfare programs.
Did you only skim the videos? This was specifically mentioned.
In which one did he say that?
-
@coliver said in Don't Stay in School:
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
What life skills are you talking about? How to work queries on Google to find answer? How to balance a checkbook? A skill that is clearly missing from middle ages folks is how to actually use the internet, but I don't think most kids suffer this problem.
My peers, the ones that I graduated high school with and then went on to work with in IT (several of them were sales and accounting people at my last position) couldn't use Google or the internet for anything but checking sports scores and finding customers. None of them could use Google to troubleshoot even the most basic computer problems. Granted that's why I was hired but still, how to use Microsoft Word should be a reasonable thing to expect from a 25-30 year old.
Or, you know, from a ten year old. That's not a high school skill, never was. Word processing is something you should be learning very, very young. That's not learning about computers, that's just basic literacy.
-
Got to talk to some Kosovo locals about education in Kosovo and they were even commenting on how bad the American educations standards are... and they are one of the two poorest countries in Europe (along with Moldova) with a per capita GDP as low as 1/10th that of the US. If they aren't impressed, we should be appalled.
-
-
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
Got to talk to some Kosovo locals about education in Kosovo and they were even commenting on how bad the American educations standards are
How do they know?
-
@Carnival-Boy said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
Got to talk to some Kosovo locals about education in Kosovo and they were even commenting on how bad the American educations standards are
How do they know?
They have both worked and were educated in the US in addition to Kosovo. She is a university classmate of mine. We both did our graduate work in Rochester, NY.
-
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
@Carnival-Boy said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
Got to talk to some Kosovo locals about education in Kosovo and they were even commenting on how bad the American educations standards are
How do they know?
They have both worked and were educated in the US in addition to Kosovo. She is a university classmate of mine. We both did our graduate work in Rochester, NY.
Yes my exwife also homeschools as well, everyone in the world pretty much knows American education is terrible, though do realise that higher education often has a lot of sway, but that's a different story.
By the way, let me take this opportunity to spam my thread on homeschooling resources:
-
@tonyshowoff said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
@Carnival-Boy said in Don't Stay in School:
@scottalanmiller said in Don't Stay in School:
Got to talk to some Kosovo locals about education in Kosovo and they were even commenting on how bad the American educations standards are
How do they know?
They have both worked and were educated in the US in addition to Kosovo. She is a university classmate of mine. We both did our graduate work in Rochester, NY.
Yes my exwife also homeschools as well, everyone in the world pretty much knows American education is terrible, though do realise that higher education often has a lot of sway, but that's a different story.
By the way, let me take this opportunity to spam my thread on homeschooling resources:
In Kosovo they were discussing how US universities just sell PhD's without needing you to do any work and how it is to the point that having an American PhD is a red flag for corruption over here now. Some people got caught in high level politics with fake degrees from the US.
-
I know I'm asking for it by asking this, but here goes.
Scott is that American's getting PhDs from those schools or non-American's just buying PhDs? And what kind of PhDs?
-
@Dashrender said in Don't Stay in School:
I know I'm asking for it by asking this, but here goes.
Scott is that American's getting PhDs from those schools or non-American's just buying PhDs? And what kind of PhDs?
What's the difference? If American universities sell PhD's, it's American education that sets the low bar for itself. The quality of education is only as high as the lowest bar that they certify for that education.
No idea what kind of PhD, any I'm sure.
